Error Fares: What They Are and How to Book Safely

error fares

Error fares are airline tickets sold at a mistaken price, like the 2019 Cathay Pacific first-class fares under $1,000. Airlines may honor or cancel them, so book without paying for anything non-refundable first.

Error fares sit at the extreme end of cheap flights, and they behave differently from ordinary sales, so the rules of thumb below matter more than the price itself.

What error fares are and why they happen

The best-known error fare of 2019 put a first-class seat from Vietnam to the United States on sale for under $1,000 round trip, against a normal price far higher. A mistake fare is usually a human or software slip: a missing fuel surcharge, a wrong currency conversion, or a fare filed for the wrong cabin.

The US Department of Transportation (DOT) describes mistaken fares as offers to sell tickets for a fare that is usually substantially lower than the intended ticket price for the class of service being sold. That definition is useful because it separates a true error from a promotion. A sale is announced by the airline; an error is noticed by travelers first and by the airline afterwards.

The result is a short, unpredictable window. Fare-tracking communities spot the price within hours, the airline fixes its filing, and the open question becomes whether tickets already issued will be flown or cancelled. The rest of this guide is about that question.

What the law says: the US rule and its 2015 change

In April 2011, the DOT issued a prohibition on post-purchase price increases for airfare. Its main aim was to stop airlines adding fees or raising the price after a customer had paid, but in practice it also covered mistake fares, as travel writer Ben Schlappig explained in 2015. A mistake fare bought in that period had to be honored under DOT regulations, which is why airlines treated these errors so cautiously and why fare hunters watched them closely.

On June 15, 2012, the DOT Enforcement Office published answers to frequently asked questions on mistaken fares. It said that once a consumer receives confirmation and the charge appears on a credit card statement or online account, a purchase has happened whether or not the fare was a mistake. It also treated a contract-of-carriage clause reserving the right to cancel a mistaken fare as an unfair and deceptive practice.

That changed on May 8, 2015. The Enforcement Office announced that, as a matter of prosecutorial discretion, it would not enforce section 399.88 for mistaken fares occurring on or after the date of the notice, provided the airline met conditions that include demonstrating that the fare was a mistake. The regulation itself stayed on the books, but as of that 2015 notice airlines gained room to cancel genuine errors. Rules differ outside the US, so a ticket bought from a non-US seller may follow different local consumer law.

A real case: Cathay Pacific, January 2019

On January 2, 2019, Ben Schlappig reported that Cathay Pacific would honor a batch of first and business class tickets it had sold by mistake over New Year’s Eve and New Year’s Day. From Vietnam to the US, the report said, a traveler could fly round trip in business class for under $700, or round trip in first class for under $1,000.

error fares
Context: error fares.

The airline had said it would decide on a Wednesday whether to honor the tickets, and it did. Its own post admitted “we made a mistake” while welcoming passengers aboard. Cathay Pacific first class cabins had in the writer’s words sold out altogether months in advance, which shows how fast an error spreads once it is public.

The lesson is not that airlines always honor errors. The Hong Kong carrier faced a choice between the cost of flying the seats and the reputational cost of cancelling bookings from travelers who had already planned trips around them, and it judged the reputational cost to be larger. A different carrier in the same position may weigh the same trade-off differently, which is why the advice in the next section assumes the ticket could vanish. Cathay Pacific chose to, partly for goodwill. The same week, travelers holding an error fare from a different carrier could have received a cancellation email instead, and nothing in the 2015 DOT notice would have stopped it.

How to book an error fare safely

Treat every error fare as a ticket that may never be flown, a rule that held in 2011, in 2015 and in 2019. The safe approach limits what you lose if the airline cancels.

  • Book directly with the airline when possible. A cancellation then comes from one company and a refund goes back to your card, with no intermediary in between.
  • Wait before buying anything else. Hotels, tours and visas should stay unbooked, or fully refundable, until the airline has stayed silent for a while or confirmed the ticket. Cathay Pacific took until the Wednesday after the sale to confirm in 2019.
  • Keep proof. The DOT’s 2012 FAQ treated the confirmation and the card charge as the moment of purchase, so save the confirmation email and the statement line.
  • Pay by credit card. If a refund is slow after a cancellation, the card issuer gives you a dispute route that a bank transfer does not.
  • Do not call the airline to ask. Calls and emails can draw attention to the fare, and an agent may cancel it when a quiet booking would have been left alone.

Error fares are one tool among several for finding low prices. The broader habit of watching sales is covered in the guide to flight deals, and low-cost carriers that publish frequent promotions are covered in the guide to budget airlines in europe. Neither depends on a mistake, and both leave you with a ticket you can count on.

Read the confirmation email closely when it arrives. It should show a ticket number, the fare paid and the routing. A booking reference with no ticket number is a reservation, not an issued ticket, and airlines find it easier to void.

Finally, keep dates flexible. A traveler who needs a fixed holiday week is badly placed for error fares, while one who can leave on a few days’ notice is the person most likely to benefit.

Frequently asked questions

Do airlines have to honor error fares?

Do airlines have to honor error fares?

Not always. The DOT’s 2012 FAQ treated a confirmed, charged purchase as binding, but its May 8, 2015 notice said the Enforcement Office would not enforce section 399.88 for mistaken fares that the airline can demonstrate were mistakes.

Has an airline ever honored an error fare?

Has an airline ever honored an error fare?

Yes. Cathay Pacific confirmed in January 2019 that it would honor first and business class tickets sold for under $1,000 and under $700 respectively on Vietnam to US routes.

When is a ticket actually purchased?

When is a ticket actually purchased?

The DOT Enforcement Office said in its June 15, 2012 answers that a purchase exists once the consumer gets confirmation and the charge shows on a credit card statement or online account.

Should I book hotels right after buying an error fare?

Should I book hotels right after buying an error fare?

No. Cathay Pacific took until the Wednesday after its 2019 mistake to confirm it would honor tickets, so wait for confirmation or book only refundable stays.